Scener from Eleuthera vacation rentals.

Eleuthera Vacation Rentals by Owner

Make reservations direct!

By Location

There is a wide variety of Eleuthera rentals available on the island ranging from cottages to some of the most exquisite vacation homes and villas in the Bahamas. Locations vary from “in town” to romantic and secluded beachfront accommodations along Eleuthera's sea shores. Some of the upscale rentals can be found along the old Club Med Beach near Governor's Harbour, North Palmetto, Double Bay, Winding Bay and Rainbow Bay.

The rentals listed here are unique as they offer their own independently managed websites. Contact with the property owners is direct. Many of these vacation homes and cottages can be found on our maps of Eleuthera where you can see nearby beaches, restaurants and points of interest.

Eleuthera vacation rentals by owner can offer real value. Read more about Eleuthera Vacation Home Rental Tips.

Eleuthera Vacation Rentals North

Marshall House - Beachfront vacation rental by owner located next to North Beach on the Caribbean side of North Eleuthera near the town of Current.  E-mail: sherryminnis[at]

Indigo Seas - Hilltop two bedroom cottage overlooking the water the water located in Rainbow Bay.  E-mail: indigoseas.bahamas[at]

Eleuthera Vacation Rentals Central

Tropical Impulse Vacation Home

Tropical Impulse

Spectacular oceanfront villa with 3 bedrooms and own bathrooms located on Atlantic side of Eleuthera, North Palmetto Point. This villa sits less than 75' from a pink sandy beach with numerous coral reefs for snorkeling just off shore. The grounds are beautifully landscaped with exotic plants and flowers. Expansive deck features shuffle board. Amenities include kayaks, bicycles and beach toys.

Touch Of Heaven vacation rental.

Touch Of Heaven

Spacious 1 bedroom, 1 bath, this vacation home, sits 85 feet above sea level with a spectacular 180 degree view of the Atlantic ocean. Within walking distance to secluded beach access with miles of undeveloped beach to explore. 1.5 miles from Governor's Harbour airport. 6 miles from center of town in Governor's Harbour. We are totally clothing optional, naturist friendly.

Off The Reef home rental.

Off The Reef

Off the Reef is a one bedroom, one bath beachfront vacation rental located in popular North Palmetto Point area on a beautiful property directly in front of miles of beaches – very secluded beaches that you can walk on for miles and see very few people. This is an excellent place for a couple to get plenty of rest and relaxation.

Conch'd Out vacation rental.

Conch'd Out

This casual and comfortable oceanfront home is located on a private palm-studded 2 acres in North Palmetto Point and on one of the island's most beautiful pink sand beaches. The two bedroom main house and one bedroom cottage accommodate up to 8 people. Relax, enjoy a cool drink, a gentle breeze and a 180 degree view of the Atlantic under the Palapa!

Da Villa Eleuthera - New 2 bedroom house Located approximately 10 minutes south of Governors Harbour Airport. View of the Atlantic and the pink sand beach.  E-mail: jimdavila[at]

One Palm Hill - Hilltop villa with views of the Atlantic less than a mile from Governor's Harbour and a short walk or one minute drive from Twin Coves beach.  E-mail: reservations[at]

Casuarina Bay - Beachfront vacation cottage with 360° deck located on the Atlantic side just northeast of Governor's Harbour.  E-mail: casuarinarentals[at]

Helios House - Large 8 acre estate Eleuthera vacation homes located on Banks Road in Governor's Harbour.  E-mail: bertrand.kan[at]

Buccaneer Hill - Historic 5 bedroom home located in the town of Governor's Harbour overlooking Cupid's Cay.  E-mail: info[at]

Eleuthera Vacation Rentals South

Point O' Vue Eleuthera vacation rental.

Point o' View

Located on Winding Bay, this 3 bedroom 3,100 square foot private home was designed by the acclaimed Nassau architect, Michael Alexiou. Views of the ocean from the front verandah are spectacular. The main living area is open-plan, with 25' cathedral ceilings and sliding glass doors to front and back verandas. The beach offers miles of sand and a cabana for meals or drinks.

Culmer Cottage vacation cottage rental.

Culmer Cottage

Experience the real Bahamas by living within a Bahamian community. Tarpum Bay is centrally located for sightseeing north/south. Our affordable Eleuthera rental cottage is near restaurants, grocery and fishing dock. We have a beautiful view of the Caribbean just steps away. We provide a fully equipped house including wifi, tv and washing machine. Check out Culmer Cottage and its great location!